(Zero Hedge)—For much of the past year we had been pounding the table on two very simple facts: not only has the US labor market been appallingly weak, with most of the jobs “gained” in 2023 and meant to signal how strong the Biden “recovery” has been, about to be revised away (as first the Philly Fed and now Bloomberg both admit), but more shockingly, all the job growth in the past few years has gone to illegal aliens.
We first pointed this out more than a year ago, and since then we have routinely repeated – again, again, and again – yet even though we made it abundantly clear what was happening…
Stunning statistic: there has been ZERO INCREASE in jobs for native-born workers in over five years, since July 2018! pic.twitter.com/mxdpmPHIbO
— zerohedge (@zerohedge) January 5, 2024
… going so far as to point out the specific immigration loophole illegals were using to work in the US for up to 5 years…
Why have all new jobs since 2018 gone to foreign-born workers (i.e. immigrants)? Because you can be an illegal immigrant in deportation proceedings (not to mention anyone seeking asylum) and get authorization to work in the US for up to 5 years, no questions asked. pic.twitter.com/VmhTBUM1I2
— zerohedge (@zerohedge) March 10, 2024
… and even fact-checking the senile, ballot-harvesting White House occupant on multiple occasions…
Fact-check:
1. Prices have never been higher and are starting to accelerate to the upside again
2. All the jobs created in the past year have been part time.
3. There has been zero job growth for native-born Americans since 2018; all jobs have gone to immigrants (mostly illegal… https://t.co/MeX7KhbaHl pic.twitter.com/OJI79p9oLp— zerohedge (@zerohedge) February 29, 2024
… we were shocked that the topic of most if not all US jobs going to illegals was still not “the biggest political talking point” of all.
How is this not the biggest political talking point right now: since October 2019, native-born US workers have lost 1.4 million jobs; over the same period foreign-born workers have gained 3 million jobs. pic.twitter.com/Z5HVWmQ24C
— zerohedge (@zerohedge) January 15, 2024
That’s about to change, however, because with just under 5 months left until the election, and with immigration by far the hottest political topic out there, others are finally starting to connect the dots we laid out more than a year ago.
The first Wall Street analyst daring to point out that the employment emperor is naked, is Standard Chartered’s global head of macro, Steve Englander who in a note titled simply enough “Immigration leading to labor-market surge” (and available to pro subscribers in the usualk place), writes that according to his estimates “undocumented immigrants account for half of job growth in FY24 so far” (the actual number is far higher but we understand his initial conservatism), and adds that “asylum seekers and humanitarian parolees explain the surge in undocumented immigrants” before concluding that the continued rise in EAD approvals likely will extend strong employment growth in 2024. In other words, “strong employment growth” for American citizens, always was and remains a fabulation, and the only job growth in the US is for illegals, who will work for below minimum wage, which also explains why inflation hasn’t spiked in the past year as millions of illegals were hired.
Below we excerpt from the Englander note because we hope that more economists, strategists and politicians will read it and grasp what we have been saying for over a year.
Echoing what we have said for months, Englander writes that immigration, particularly illegal immigration, “is a political flashpoint that has also become an important factor in assessing economic performance. Detailed data from US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) and US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) suggest that half of non-farm payroll (NFP) growth to date for FY24 (started 1 October 2023) has been from undocumented immigrants who have received an Employment Authorization Document (EAD)” (he defines undocumented immigrants as those who entered the US through non-traditional immigration pathways, such as asylum seekers, parolees, and refugees).
The ability to track EAD issuance to undocumented workers is an advantage in estimating how much they have contributed to employment growth. NFP counts workers with an EAD just like any other. Using that data, it is easy to estimate that undocumented workers have added 109k jobs per month to NFP out of the average 231k increase so far in FY24.
Which is staggering since last night we showed that about 100K monthly jobs are purely statistical distortions, and the real pace of job growth in the past year has been around 130K.
So if 100K jobs per month are fabricated birth/death artifacts (i.e., not real jobs but a statistically goalseeked fudge factor), and another 109K jobs per month are illegal aliens, that leaves just about 11K jobs for everyone else, i.e., law abiding Americans.
It also means that the labor market in the US has – for the past year – been an absolute catastrophe and harbinger of economic disaster (and is why last night we pointed out “The “Unexpected” Reason Why The Fed Will Rush To Cut Rates As Soon As Possible“).
But wait, as Englander himself admits, the 109K estimate of illegal aliens “may be an underestimate since undocumented immigrants often have limited access to benefits, so they may be heavily motivated to find employment. The GDP impact might be lower if these workers are less educated and face language barriers in the work force.”
Here, Englander – who did not do the Birth/Death analysis – writes that if one excludes these illegal immigrant workers, “NFP may be running at c.125k per month” and adds that “such a pace is not recession but is hardly boom time and represents a moderate underlying pace of labor demand. It should make the 231k FY24 pace of headline NFP less worrisome to the FOMC. FOMC participants might be less hawkish if the impact of undocumented immigrants on NFP was well estimated and understood.”
Of course, if the Std Chartered analyst were to factor for the true collapse in Birth-Death adjustments discussed yesterday by Bloomberg…
… the real number would be, well, zero!
While the political reason behind the propaganda misrepresentation of the US jobs market is simple: after all, in an election year it is imperative that the Biden economy be portrayed as glowingly as possible, even if it means lying about everything, the cascading consequences from this fabrication are staggering. As Englander concedes, “this added labor supply also may have shifted trend employment and GDP growth, making it hard to gauge whether a strong NFP or even GDP number reflects supply or demand. If supply is driving upside surprises, the takeaway is more optimism that inflation will slow. If demand, the opposite. Soft economic data should be seen through the lens of added labor supply, while strong data releases are ambiguous.”
Taking a closer look, such increased labor supply – from illegals – should put downward pressure on wage growth relative to a baseline with less immigration (documented or not). In measures such as average hourly earnings, the disinflationary impact would be two-fold:
- lower wages overall from an increase of labour supply relative to labour demand and
- a composition effect because the undocumented immigrants often work in low wage industries even with EADs.
However, this is likely to be a gradual process, so the low wage impact may not be immediately visible. In addition, insofar as these workers’ wages reflect relatively low productivity, the composition effect on wages will be offset by a composition effect on productivity – unit labour cost growth may be unchanged.
These observations notwithstanding, one can assume that the contribution of undocumented immigrants to employment is unlikely to change any time soon. Indeed, over the last 12 months an average of 280k undocumented immigrants per month have been encountered nationally, most whom can or will be eligible to work legally in coming months. The same methodology suggests that these workers contributed about one-third of FY23 employment growth.
It gets worse.
The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that in fiscal 2023 a further 860k individuals crossed the border without contact with US immigration authorities. While these people are not eligible for EADs they may still work off the books or with fake or borrowed documents. As such, their output and spending will show up in GDP, although it is unlikely that much if any of their “labor input” is captured. These, along with others (tourists who overstay visas, students whose visas have expired, etc.) are technically undocumented as well. But since few are eligible for EADs, it is unlikely that they are captured in any BLS survey.
In any event, Englander estimates that over 800k undocumented immigrants found jobs in FY23, and assumes that 64.2% of EAD recipients (the average for the foreign-born population) are working. However, the employment rate may well be higher since these are likely to be “very motivated” workers, since they are not generally eligible for unemployment insurance and other benefits, so work is a necessity for many.
Ssing this calculation, and since Nonfarm Payrolls grew 3.1 million in FY23, the 800k would represent more than 25% of NFP growth.
But what about those record numbers of multiple job-holders we have also discussed.
Ah yes, to address that Englander next calculates an augmented version of NFP that includes agricultural workers, self- and family-employed workers from the household survey (CPS), and subtracts multiple-job holders. By this measure employment grew 2.7 million (this is largely due to a rise in multiple-job holders, which are subtracted to avoid double counting). So far in FY24, on average over 170k undocumented immigrants have received EAD approvals every month and c.109k have found work based on employment rates. And since NFP has averaged 230k per month, these workers likely accounted for around half of job growth. Again, this number excludes the roughly 100k per month addition coming from birth/death calculation distortions which will soon be revised away as Bloomberg’s chief economist Anna Wong calculated, before concluding that “by the end of the year the printed level of nonfarm-payrolls for 2024 likely will overstate true employment by at least one million.”
Again, this means that when stripping away the 100K in statistical “jobs” from the 230K monthly payroll number, and then removing the 109K in illegal alien workers, the number of jobs added by ordinary, legal, native-born, Americans in the past year has been – more or less – zero.
We, for one, can’t wait for Joe Biden to explain how this was remotely possible during his upcoming debate with Trump in three weeks time.
Much more in the full must-read note – especially to those who will be prepping Donald Trump for his upcoming debate – from Englander available to pro subscribers in the usual place.
Three Reasons a Coffee Gift Set From This Christian Company Is Perfect for Christmas
When you’re searching for a Christmas gift that’s meaningful, useful, and rooted in faith, you don’t want to settle for anything generic. This season is filled with noise — mass-produced products, last-minute picks, and trends that fade as quickly as they appear. But one gift stands apart because it blends genuine quality with a message that matters: a coffee gift set from Promised Grounds Coffee.
This small Christian-owned company has become a favorite among believers who want to support faith-driven businesses while giving friends and family something they’ll actually enjoy. Here are three reasons a Promised Grounds Coffee gift set may be the most thoughtful and impactful present you give this year.
1. It’s Truly Delicious Coffee
Too many “gift-worthy” coffees look beautiful in the package but disappoint when the cup is poured. Promised Grounds takes the opposite approach — exceptional taste first, thoughtful presentation second.
Their beans are sourced with care, roasted in small batches, and crafted to bring out a rich, smooth flavor profile that appeals to both casual drinkers and true coffee lovers. Whether someone enjoys bold, dark roasts or lighter, more delicate blends, every sip reflects quality that stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the biggest specialty brands.
Simply put: this coffee is good. Really good. Some say it’s absolutely fantastic. If you want a gift that won’t be re-gifted, ignored, or shoved in a cabinet, this is it.
2. It Spreads the Word While Serving a Real Purpose
There are many Christian gifts that are meaningful… but not exactly practical. There are also useful gifts that have nothing to do with faith. Promised Grounds Coffee bridges both worlds beautifully.
Each gift set delivers an encouraging, faith-centered message through its packaging and presentation — a simple but powerful reminder of God’s goodness during the Christmas season. The cups are especially popular and serve as a daily reminder of the blessings from our Lord. At the same time, the product itself is something people will actually use and appreciate every single day.
It’s a gift that uplifts the spirit and fills the mug. A gift that points loved ones toward Scripture while still being part of the normal rhythm of life. And in a culture that increasingly pushes faith to the margins, giving a gift that quietly but confidently honors Christ can make a deeper impact than you might expect.
3. It’s Affordable, Valuable, and Elegantly Presented
Many people want to give something meaningful without breaking their Christmas budget. Promised Grounds Coffee strikes that perfect balance — the sets look and feel premium, but the price remains accessible.
The packaging is classy, clean, and gift-ready, making it ideal for:
- Family members of all ages
- Co-workers or employees
- Church friends or small-group leaders
- Hosts, neighbors, and last-minute gift needs
It’s the kind of gift that feels more expensive than it is — and more thoughtful than most of what you’ll find on store shelves.
The Perfect Blend of Faith, Flavor, and Christmas Cheer
A coffee gift set from Promised Grounds Coffee checks every box: a gift that tastes amazing, conveys your faith, supports a Christian business, and brings daily enjoyment to the person who receives it. In a season when so many gifts are forgotten, this one stands out for all the right reasons.
If you want a Christmas present that reflects your values and delivers genuine joy, Promised Grounds Coffee is the perfect place to start.
…no surprise here…illegals also get the biggest amount of ‘free’ cell phones/air time…’free’ food…’free’ medical/health care…’free’ housing…’free’ airline/bus transportation…’free’ dental/eye care…’free education incl. in their native language’…’free’ clothing…’free legal protection’…’free SNAP card benefits’…has anything else been over looked or missed ?…they probably get that ‘free’ too…
Tax free business situations. Don’t forget that one. Higher pay scales for speaking more than one languages. The best benefit of all; A care free life of crime because the police won’t even bother with them.
THE BIDEN REGIME is paying over 500 corporations (look more closely at TYSONS) to lay off American workers and replace them with ILLEGAL INVADERS! A seldom mentioned bit of REAL NEWS!
Red Blue! Red Blue! Parrot in a cage. No my dear friend Mr Star Gladiator. You are the paying those corporations to lay off American workers. That is your tax dollars, hard at work. There will be no Boston Harbor moment or tea party for you. Live an entire life subjected to taxation without representation. The beatings will continue until morale improves.
Incoherent, sonny, try making a bit of sense in your babbling responses!
AFFIRMATIVE —- cross border ILLEGALLY and receive a $1,500 debit card! Free phone and free airlines ticket to any destination —- although most ILLEGALS appear to already possess smartphones or the highly expensive satellite phones!
One of our nations besetting faults is the drive for cheaper labor. So we got indenture servants, chattel slavery, child labor and now a flood of illegals. There was a movie about 10 years ago called “Food Inc”. The had footage from a pig slaughterhouse for a large company. They used illegal aliens because if they complained they were easy to fire.
They are working because they want to. I am an employer, and our men would rather lye in a tent. They stand in front of business’s with a help wanted signs, with “I’ll work for food” signs . So many small business’s have closed down for the lack of help. So, let’s start with, what is wrong with the native born? Meth and fentanyl instead of employment.
Another issue is the removal of driver licenses for every infraction, leaving them depended on rides, or leaves them house bound.
We have been watching this come for over 20 years, and now my husband is the sole employee of his own business.
BULLTWACKY! YOU hired clowns for NAM, the National Association of Manufacturers and the globalist/commie US Chamber of Commerce (the American branch, I do not follow the Shanghai branch), have been promoting this propaganda aince the 1980s to enrich your maggot selves and DESTROY AMERICA —- too successful, sad to say!
Looking around and seeing where I live alot of “Brown” people and then people who you know are not English speaking (White) people this didn’t require Wall Street it did require them to announce the truth which they have finally done.
The Facts are these people want everything given to them. Read that sentence again, they want everything given to them. They are lazy like the South Park “Where has my water park gone” song. Meanwhile many others just want to be high on something, or sticking there wee wee into something constantly. That is a mental illness. The only thing your wee wee should be going into is your wife and making children there is no problems with that if it must 5 times a day, healthy; happy marriage.
Personally I’d earn far more money being on government systems as an unemployed person than being a licensed professional. Year after year, a negative tax rate and business loss. Thank you to the lending community for making sure I never work again.
Was looking at summer jobs at Adams county Colorado. Looks like the entirety of the work has gone to illegal aliens. Or as the lunatic progressives would call them; Our new undocumented citizens. If one is not bi lingual, one could not even be able to communicate with the majority of co workers and therefore, you do not get hired. Because; Equality. All your co workers would rob you blind anyways. The usual suspects.
Adams county is so inclusive; No straight white people need apply. Those without a mental illness may not fit in. Bilinguals, trans, minority, or basically anyone who’s not white gets automatic higher pay scales and better benefits. / At Adams County, we hire exceptional employees and provide them with top-notch opportunities to grow, expand their capabilities, and reach their full potential. Adams County cultivates an inclusive and innovative culture and offers employees exciting and dynamic challenges to build successful careers as they help us become the most innovative and inclusive county in America.
Just one question; When do the deportations start? Sign me up for that job.
THE BIDEN REGIME is paying over 500 corporations (look more closely at TYSONS) to lay off American workers and replace them with ILLEGAL INVADERS! A seldom mentioned bit of REAL NEWS!
I really don’t get why everyone cites inflation numbers as if the current number has anything at all to do with current price levels. Inflation is a measure of price pressure and is indicative of future price levels only. A robust economy with a growing population will always have some inflationary pressure mainly due to supply and demand. This pressure self regulates. Dumping huge amounts of printed dollars, artificially dropping interest rates for political purposes deflates the purchasing power of the dollar, investors pull back on projects fueled by yesterdays values and convert to to value retaining assets ie real estate, gold, other markets. Any new investment is made with cheap borrowing that dumps even more dollars into the market. All of that creates inflationary pressure as producers cannot recoup past investments ROI without raising prices to absorb the devaluation of the currency.
Nothing will ever bring prices back down short of de-inflation as the price levels were not from supply and demand of the marketplace but from monetary policy devaluing currency based upon fiat, trust. The US dollar has new real value except future economic activity. De-inflation is not caused by a government suddenly giving value to its worthless currency but from the flooding the market place with supply ie products or labor. Highly unlikely investors will sell wares with little or no return so labor supply is key. Free and cheap ( the bottom falls out of the market) labor removes the expense incurred by producers theoretically enabling them to profit and lower prices. Fantasy because it assumes investors will willingly give up profit.
A cynical person would see an opportunity to nationalize production and prices.
As for EAD was it, allowing immigrants to work only 5 years mind you without documentation. A sizable amount of their disposable income leaves this country for their native home. Something tells me they pay taxes and probably are issued some ID to pay into SS and FICA. The proverbial camel nose under the tent. Expect those behind this ploy to then claim those illegals have invested in this country and have earned citizenship. It’s planned.
Paul, you’re making too much sense. Stop it. NORM. National Organization for Raw Materials.
There is no wealth other than the products of raw materials and the labor associated with that.
Sadly, even the people setting the policies at our top levels do not understand such simple concepts.
If there were economic theory tests to become a high level politician; We’d have no high level politicians.
The beatings will continue until morale improves.
They don’t call illegals our replacement for nothing.
If a penny saved is a penny earned, then how ever much the company owners saved by hiring illegal, felonious, non-U.S.Americans, needs to count as treason money and they all need jail time.