(Daily Caller)—The federal ban on at-home distilling — a hold over from the Prohibition Era — violates the U.S. Constitution, a new lawsuit argues.
The Hobby Distillers Association, an organization with over 1,300 members represented by the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI), filed a federal lawsuit this month against the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TBB) and Department of Justice (DOJ) over the government’s ban on at-home distilling. The ban is not just “bad policy,” CEI’s General Counsel Dan Greenberg told the Daily Caller News Foundation, it’s also “inconsistent with a proper view of the limited government constraints of the Constitution.”
“The Constitution created a Federal Government of limited and enumerated powers,” the lawsuit states. “The at-home distilling ban is beyond all of the powers of Congress to enact under the Constitution.”
President Jimmy Carter signed legislation legalizing the practice of homebrewing federally in 1978, though home distilling remained illegal, according to the Smithsonian.
The lawsuit argues that the ban does not fall under Congress’ authority to regulate interstate commerce, as it operates locally, or the federal government’s taxing power, as it “raises no revenue.”
“The interstate sales of beer and wine are regulated in much the same way as the interstate sales of distilled beverage alcohol are regulated, but beer and wine can lawfully be produced at home under federal law,” it states.
Distilling alcohol at home carries consequences of up to five years in prison or up to a $10,000 fine, per the TTB.
“While individuals of legal drinking age may produce wine or beer at home for personal or family use, Federal law strictly prohibits individuals from producing distilled spirits at home,” the TTB website states.
The activity would be properly regulated at the state level, CEI attorney Devin Watkins said in a statement. In some places, such as Alaska, Arizona, Massachusetts and Missouri, state laws allow individuals to distill alcohol at home, according to Reason.
The Ohio state senate introduced a bill in January 2023 that would permit any citizen over 21 to make up to 100 gallons of moonshine a year, according to News 5 Cleveland.
But because it’s still banned at the federal level, even home distillers in states that permit the practice could risk prosecution.
“Like so many laws in our overcriminalized society, however, there is uncertainty about how rigorously these laws are enforced,” C. Jarrett Dieterle, resident senior fellow at the R Street Institute, wrote for Reason earlier this year. “Similar to homebrewers in the ’70s and ’80s, it’s likely that some of America’s craft distilleries started out as clandestine home distilling operations.”
“We believe that, under the Constitution, at-home distilling is an activity properly regulated at the state and not the federal level."
CEI's @LibertyDevin on our lawsuit with the Home Distillers Association against the federal ban on at-home distilling.https://t.co/Ci4w1w5fQW
— Competitive Enterprise Institute (@ceidotorg) December 15, 2023
Greenberg said the ban is “somewhere between 100 and 150 years old” and is part of a federal tax collecting statute, which appears “completely unrelated to the legitimate use of the powers of the federal government.”
“It’s perfectly legal to distill beverage alcohol in some circumstances, as long as you don’t do it on your home property,” he said. “And it’s perfectly legal to distill fuel alcohol on your home property, in some circumstances, as long as you have a permit…the product that is produced with respect to fuel alcohol and beverage alcohol are chemically identical.”
The plaintiffs are just trying to explore the hobby of distilling beverage alcohol, but want to do it legally, Greenberg said. The lawsuit notes that multiple “have legally distilled before and would be able to distill if the law allowed them to do so.”
The Hobby Distillery Association’s efforts to lobby Congress to repeal the federal prohibition have “been blocked by an industry that does not want more competition,” the lawsuit states.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].
Retirement Clarity Starts With One Step
In a world where financial markets fluctuate wildly and economic uncertainties loom large, achieving clarity in your retirement planning can feel like an elusive dream. But what if the path to a secure future begins with just one decisive step?
That step is choosing to take control of your retirement accounts by partnering with a trustworthy company to establish a self-directed IRA. This simple yet powerful move empowers you to break free from conventional constraints and steer your financial destiny with confidence.
Traditional retirement accounts, often tied to stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, are rooted in strategies that have not evolved much since the mid-20th century. These default options are typically designed with the advisor’s interests in mind—think high management fees, limited investment choices, and a one-size-fits-all approach that prioritizes institutional profits over your personalized needs.
Advisors benefit from ongoing commissions and asset-based charges, while retirees are left navigating a system that may not align with modern economic realities or individual risk tolerances. It’s no wonder so many feel trapped in a cycle of underwhelming performance and hidden costs.
Enter the self-directed IRA: a game-changer that puts you firmly in the driver’s seat. By working with a reliable partner experienced in self-directed accounts, you gain the freedom to explore a broader range of investment opportunities beyond the standard fare. This includes alternatives assets like physical precious metals, allowing for true diversification tailored to your vision.
The real advantage lies in the tangible control it offers—decide where your money goes, when to pivot, and how to optimize for tax advantages inherent in IRAs. No more relying on outdated models that favor the financial industry; instead, you’re building a portfolio that reflects your goals, whether that’s growth, stability, or legacy planning.
The beauty of this approach is its simplicity and accessibility. A trustworthy partner handles the administrative complexities, ensuring compliance with IRS regulations while you focus on strategy. This isn’t about chasing trends—it’s about reclaiming agency in an era where passive investing often leads to passive results. Retirees who make this shift report greater peace of mind, knowing their nest egg is working harder for them, not for someone else.
If retirement clarity has felt out of reach, start today with that one step. Connect with Augusta Precious Metals and unlock the potential of true financial independence. Your future self will thank you.
